Because the Steven Olsen-Smith and you can Hershel Parker mention, the fresh interest in the Whitman problem might have been to speak inexactly from the clusters and even individual poems (Olsen-Smith and you may Parker 1997). Experts appear to relate to, say, „Outside of the Cradle Endlessly Rocking“ or „Calamus“ instead of specifying hence model is meant and regularly for the implication that comment retains for everybody brands out-of an excellent poem or class. Offered Whitman’s current standing just like the icon of homosexual The united states, and because of the imprecision in which critics has typically known Whitman texts, a volatile mix has been preparing inside Whitman problem.
One can see why the newest limits was highest: because the Helms highlights, you’ll argue that „Live oak“ as opposed to the fuzzier „Calamus“ ’s the „simply sustained treatments for homosexual like in every off their poetry“ (p
However, Helms’s selection of messages composed a small crucial storm. The guy articulated his editorial coverage the following: „I allow the ‚Live Oak‘ poems within their earliest had written form-which is, as they appeared in the next Departs out of Lawn inside the 1860 throughout the mode Whitman recognized getting publication. I’ve only eliminated her or him out of ‚Calamus‘ and you will recovered them to Whitman’s brand new purchase“ (Martin 1992, 187). Helms’s editing of your own series acquired blistering problem when you look at the 1996 regarding Hershel Parker, just who pointed out that Helms had submit a combined text message distinct from Whitman got previously compiled (the fresh modified 1860 brands of „Live oak“ poems in the brand new sequence’s purchase). „In the 1992, Alan Helms typed the fresh new „Live-oak with Moss“ succession from inside the a text regarding essays for the Whitman (Martin 1992)“ weiterlesen